ArcGIS Living Atlas

Towards an Accessible Basemap

Recently, users have asked us about basemaps that are accessible and/or color-blind-safe. In particular they have asked for maps that comply with WCAG (Web Content Accessibility Guidelines) standards, and the US Federal ‘Section 508’ equivalent. This presents a few challenges. A map can be a complex structure that relies on a well-developed hierarchy, and a basemap is an extreme example of that. Imposing a new set of rules on top can be a daunting prospect!

What follows is an attempt to get to grips with the graphic aspects and to present you with some alternatives.

What are the standards?

This is a difficult question, at least in how these standards relate to maps. The graphic requirements tend to concentrate on legibility of text (WCAG-AA standards call for a contrast ratio of at least 4.5 between text and background). It suggests that for many of our maps we could meet this requirement simply by changing labels to black, placing a halo behind them to act as the ‘background’, and leaving the rest of the content alone. A map is much more than just its labels though, and we want to improve the accessibility of the map content as well.

What is different about a basemap?

John Nelson has talked about ‘BASE-maps’ versus ‘base-MAPS’. A BASE-map is a deliberately subdued background map used as an underpinning for your information (think ‘Light/Dark Gray’ or ‘Topographic’). This is challenging if it is an accessible map, where contrast between symbols is important. A ‘base-MAP’ is a stronger reference map (think ‘National Geographic Style’), where your information is added to the overall picture. That makes accessibility easier to build-in. Either way there needs to be some room in the map hierarchy for the user’s information.

How can we approach this?

We need to find a balance between accessibility and functionality.

So, we can use a color-blind-safe palette and increase contrast between map features, to make the map work for a broader audience. This means that the map will use at least some strong colors and tones. We can avoid ‘fussy’ fonts that might be difficult to pick out of the background. And we can increase the size of labels (but carefully – we don’t want to swamp the basemap with words!). Haloes help with the legibility of labels, but they can be destructive to the rest of the map information

Ultimately, we may have to consider cutting some of the content of the map.

The Results

I have created a map design that tries to walk a line between accessibility, and functionality as a basemap. It is more of ‘base-MAP’, but I’ve tried not to go overboard with it.

The Topographic Basemap and the new ‘Accessible’ design

Two versions of the map are available:

Here are the details:

Color blindness simulations

Using the basemaps

These basemap layers will be available for you to use at the URLs linked above for the foreseeable future. The map content is updated with our regular basemap data updates. I may make periodic changes to these map styles as needed based on your feedback and our experience using the maps.

If they prove popular, we’ll consider incorporating them into the core basemap set. We’ll try to give you plenty of warning if we decide to shut these URLs down and replace them.

I would appreciate any feedback you care to provide, either via the comments section below, or directly at askinner@esri.com.

Thanks!  Andy Skinner

Color-blindness suitability was assessed using ‘Color Oracle‘. Color contrast was assessed using contrast-ratio.com. Thanks to Mark Harrower and Emily Meriam for their input.

About the author

Andy is a Cartographic Designer who has been working with Esri in Redlands for 11 years, on projects such as the Urban Observatory, and Green Infrastructure, and most recently on the creation of some of Esri's vector basemaps. Prior to Esri, he was Manager of Cartographic Design at Rand McNally, and before that a Senior Cartographer at GeoSystems/MapQuest. He is originally from England, and worked for a number of years at what is now the University of Derby before moving to the USA. Andy can be contacted at: askinner@esri.com

2
Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
newest oldest
Christine Fandrich Fandrich
Christine Fandrich Fandrich

Great map! I’m really happy to see the effort put in to create a map that creates better accessibility. Personally, I find this map to be one of the more appealing maps. I’m not certain if it is a settings issue that I have overlooked. I followed the instructions listed in the link for creating a custom webmap gallery, however, the 4.1 and 4.2 are tile layers do not appear within the gallery. It could also be that I missed the point. They show up when I search “Basemap” in the Living Atlas. I see that there are two versions… Read more »

Next Article

Something in the water: the mythology of Snow’s map of cholera

Read this article